The recent Copa America tournament in the United States has brought to light an often-overlooked aspect of soccer logistics: the playing surface. With players and coaches expressing significant concerns over the quality of the grass pitches laid over existing artificial turf, it’s crucial to understand the process, the reasoning behind it, and the potential negative effects on the game and its players.
Copa America and Player Concerns
The current Copa America tournament has been a stark example of these challenges. Stadiums like Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta and AT&T Stadium in Dallas, primarily designed for American football, had temporary grass installed on the pitch for the event. Players and coaches, particularly from the Argentine national team, have been vocal about the issues they’ve faced.
After Argentina's 2-0 victory over Canada, head coach Lionel Scaloni and several players criticized the playing surface at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. They described it as "a disaster" and "frustrating," highlighting how the grass "jumped" and felt unstable. Argentine goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez referred to it as a "trampoline," where the grass would bounce unpredictably, complicating movements and increasing the risk of injuries.
Weston McKennie, a midfielder for the USMNT, echoed these concerns, stating that playing on the patchy, laid grass was frustrating. He noted that the surface would break up with each step, making it challenging to maintain balance and control.
The Process of Laying Grass Over Turf
Stadiums originally designed for American football often use artificial turf due to its durability and lower maintenance compared to natural grass. However, for high-profile soccer tournaments like the Copa America, natural grass on the pitch is preferred. Here's how the transition from turf to grass typically occurs:
Inspection and Cleaning: The existing artificial turf surface is inspected and cleaned to remove any debris that could affect the new grass layer.
Preparation of the Base: A geotextile fabric is often placed over the artificial turf. This fabric acts as a barrier to protect the turf and help with drainage.
Laying Sod Panels: Sod panels, which are pre-grown sections of grass, are transported from specialized farms, often in refrigerated trailers to maintain their freshness. These panels are then laid out on the prepared surface, meticulously pieced together to cover the entire field.
Irrigation and Lighting: To promote root growth and maintain the grass, an advanced irrigation system is installed under the topsoil layer. Additionally, artificial grow lights may be used to ensure the grass receives adequate light, especially in covered stadiums.
Final Adjustments: Grounds crews then make final adjustments to ensure the grass is even and securely in place, often performing several rounds of watering and mowing.
Reasoning Behind Temporary Grass Installations for Copa America 2024
The main reason for laying temporary grass over existing turf on pitches in stadiums for Copa America 2024 is to meet the playing standards required by soccer's governing bodies, such as FIFA, which prefers natural grass for top-level competitions. Natural grass is favored for its performance characteristics, including:
Ball Behavior: Natural grass provides a more predictable surface for ball movement, affecting passes, shots, and overall gameplay.
Player Safety: Grass is generally softer and provides better shock absorption than artificial turf, reducing the risk of injuries.
Heat Management: Natural grass tends to be cooler than synthetic surfaces, which can heat up significantly under direct sunlight.
Given these benefits, temporary grass installations become necessary for international tournaments held in multipurpose stadiums that primarily feature artificial turf for other sports.
Negative Effects on Soccer Players
Despite the best efforts to provide a high-quality playing surface, temporary grass installations can have several drawbacks:
Inconsistent Surface: Temporary grass often struggles to match the consistency of permanently installed grass fields. Issues such as uneven sections, gaps between sod panels, and varying soil compaction can affect gameplay. Players may find the surface unpredictable, impacting their control and performance.
Poor Rooting: Since the grass is laid just days or weeks before matches, it doesn’t have sufficient time to develop deep roots. This can result in the grass shifting or lifting during play, creating patches of exposed soil and increasing the risk of slips and falls.
Drainage Problems: Effective drainage is crucial for a playable soccer field. Temporary grass fields often suffer from poor drainage, leading to waterlogged areas that can become slippery and hazardous. In contrast, permanently installed fields are designed with advanced drainage systems that handle heavy rainfall better.
Durability Issues: High-intensity soccer matches exert significant wear and tear on the playing surface. Temporary grass is more prone to damage, quickly developing divots and bare spots. This not only affects the aesthetics but also poses injury risks to players.
Variable Playing Conditions: The temporary nature of the grass means it may not acclimate well to local conditions. For instance, if the sod panels come from a different climate, the grass might not respond predictably to the weather, affecting its resilience and playability.
Why the Grass Isn’t Good Enough
The primary issues with the grass fields at Copa America stem from the inherent limitations of temporary installations. The hurried preparation, lack of sufficient rooting time, and adaptation challenges all contribute to the subpar quality.
Preparation and Timing: The process of laying the sod panels often happens within a short timeframe before the matches. For instance, in Atlanta, the grass was laid just five days before the opening match. Such a brief period is insufficient for the grass to establish a robust root system, leading to instability and shifting during play.
Topsoil and Subsurface Quality: The quality of the topsoil and subsurface preparation is another critical factor. If the base layer is not adequately prepared, the grass will not root well, and drainage will be compromised. Inadequate drainage can lead to waterlogged sections, making the field slippery and uneven.
Climate and Environmental Factors: Temporary grass fields must adapt to local climate conditions, which can vary significantly. In Dallas, the Kentucky bluegrass used was transported from Colorado. This grass may not have acclimated well to the Texas climate, affecting its resilience and performance.
Wear and Tear: High-intensity matches, especially in a tournament setting with frequent games, exacerbate the wear and tear on the temporary grass. The lack of deep roots means the grass can easily be uprooted, leading to divots and bare patches that degrade the playing surface quickly.
Addressing the Challenges
To improve the quality of temporary grass fields, several steps can be taken:
Extended Preparation Time: Allowing more time between laying the grass and the first match can help the grass establish better roots, enhancing stability and durability.
Improved Subsurface Preparation: Ensuring the base layer is well-prepared with appropriate topsoil and drainage systems can mitigate many issues related to poor rooting and waterlogging.
Climate-Adaptive Grass Varieties: Using grass varieties that are better suited to the local climate can improve the grass's resilience and performance.
Advanced Maintenance Techniques: Employing advanced irrigation, mowing, and light management systems can help maintain the grass's health and playability throughout the tournament.
The Copa America tournament has highlighted the complexities and challenges of using temporary grass installations over existing turf in stadiums. While the intention is to provide a superior playing surface for soccer, the reality often falls short, leading to frustrations and safety concerns among players. By understanding the process, recognizing the limitations, and implementing better practices, organizers can work towards providing a more consistent and reliable playing surface, ensuring the safety and enjoyment of the game.
Comments